I'm writing this at 1 a.m. In the two hours of CNN commentary since the end of the main stage debate, one of the most repeated observations of a parade of commentators was that instead of frontrunner Trump being on the defensive throughout the evening, it was Rubio.
Especially over Rubio's immigration positions.
That was my take two hours ago when we released this statement to the national media:
The anticipated ganging up on the main stage happened less to Trump tonight than to Rubio for his leadership in bringing the Gang of Eight immigration bill to the Senate floor. Cornered several times by different candidates, Rubio still advanced the same end goal of providing lifetime work permits to millions of illegal aliens to compete with vulnerable American workers. In a foreign policy debate, candidates failed to speak up for an immigration policy that is good for American workers but everybody in both debates acknowledged that legal immigration can pose security threats and requires special consideration during this period of terrorism.
The particularly good news for us who fought fiercely against Rubio's Gang of Eight amnesty and immigration expansion bill in 2013 and 2014 is that CNN commentators across the ideological spectrum all agreed that spotlighting Rubio's role in that legislation really hurts him in the campaign.
I don't say that because I'm gleeful about Rubio being damaged politically but because it is wonderful to hear all those pundits agree that the Gang of Eight is immensely unpopular.
Back in 2013, we were constantly informed by most news media that OPPOSING the Gang of Eight was a kind of political suicide.
Many of you activist citizens out there had a role in this. Hugh Hewitt, one of the moderators in the debate, said afterwards that over the last five weeks, the most requested debate subject mentioned to him on twitter was to have Rubio and Cruz discuss immigration in depth.
Most of those talking on CNN said they believed that Cruz got the best of those exchanges with his attacks on Rubio's leadership on the Gang of Eight.
Here are some of our tweets about this part of the Republican debate tonight:
CNN puts Rubio on spot for his leadership for the Gang of 8 amnesty. He dodges. #GOPDebate
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Rubio treats his Gang of 8 bill without ever mentioning it was about doubling legal immigration first decade #GOPDebate
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Paul: "Marco has more allegiance to Chuck Schumer"
— NumbersUSA (@NumbersUSA) December 16, 2015
Paul: Rubio is the weakest on immigration. He wants open-borders.
— NumbersUSA (@NumbersUSA) December 16, 2015
Cruz hits big trust issue by noting that Rubio campaigned for Senate to fight against amnesty & then led the effort to pass one. Irrefutable
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Cruz: "I led the fight against [Rubio's] amnesty" #GOPDebate
— NumbersUSA (@NumbersUSA) December 16, 2015
Cruz mentions Jeff Sessions & Steve King by name as who he stood with on Gang of 8 bill. That's tying yourself to some major fence posts
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Paul points out that Rubio pushed the Gang of Eight amnesty bill and says he's the weakest candidate on #immigration https://t.co/R8JjLFal5G
— NumbersUSA (@NumbersUSA) December 16, 2015
Apparently Rubio supports more enforcement so he can get what he really wants: work permits for illegal aliens to compete with Am workers
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
CNN clueless to ? Rubio about support for citizenship for illegal aliens rather than about work permits as if the work permits weren't issue
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Rubio supported "I-squared" bill to TRIPLE H-1b visas. This would displace Americans and suppress wages.
#GOPdebate pic.twitter.com/kolDIFvHYJ
— NumbersUSA (@NumbersUSA) December 16, 2015
Rubio shows cluelessness that imm policy affects Am. workers & wages by specifying "work permits" as his supposed step back from Gang of 8.
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Cruz should have talked about his new H-1B bill Rubio was right that Cruz supported more H-1Bs Cruz should have owned up & said why a change
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Cruz doesn't "intend to support legalization." #GOPDebate
— NumbersUSA (@NumbersUSA) December 16, 2015
Cruz attempts to create separation on #immigration between Rubio and himself by referring to G8 amnesty #GOPDebate
— NumbersUSA (@NumbersUSA) December 16, 2015
In first #immigration question, Rubio sticks by his "enforcement first, amnesty later" line which is contradictory to his G8 bill #GOPDebate
— NumbersUSA (@NumbersUSA) December 16, 2015
Paul: Rubio's G8 bill opposed new border security req. for refugees & foreign students
— NumbersUSA (@NumbersUSA) December 16, 2015
NEAR CONSENSUS ON PAUSE FOR SYRIAN REFUGEE RESETTLEMENT
Immediately after the early debate of the four candidates with low polling numbers, I put out this statement to the national media:
All four candidates in the first debate made a compelling case for pausing refugee resettlement from the Syria region as not only best for the refugees and our security but also better for the long term prospects of the region.
The granting of a marriage immigrant visa to a woman whose social media showed terrorist proclivities was at the heart of the candidates' refusal to trust the government to properly vet new refugees from a region of terrorism. The big news there was that Graham stepped back from the Gang of Eight "comprehensive immigration reform" bill he co-authored and has steadfastly championed and indicated he wouldn't support it today without modification based on this season of terrorism.
Santorum broke important new ground in this year's debates by noting pleas from religious leaders to stop moving moderate Muslims and minority Christians out of the region. He said their argument is that if re-settled the moderates won't come back to Syria and that they are needed back to help re-establish a Syrian state that can be cooperative with the U.S.
There was almost as much agreement in the main stage debate, although moderators did not press each for an answer.
Here was some of the blogging on that part of the debates:
Undercard all agreed: San Bernardino case of giving marriage immigrant green card to terrorist shows govt vetting processes not tobe trusted
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
A CIS study found that 12 refugees can be helped in safe zones for same $$ to resettle 1 in the U.S.
#GOPdebate pic.twitter.com/e34mNG2c12
— NumbersUSA (@NumbersUSA) December 16, 2015
Huckabee: Obama said 23x he couldn't do exec amnesty, then woke up one day and found a pen in one hand and a phone in the other
#GOPDebate
— NumbersUSA (@NumbersUSA) December 16, 2015
Moderator Hewitt reminds Graham that he was leader in Gang of 8 amnesty and that might be retarding his popularity in this race #GOPDebate
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Asked if he'd sign Congress-passed DREAM amnesty, Santorum says amnesty talk attracting surges young ppl at Mexican border #GOPDebate
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Huck wouldn't continue "unconstitutional" Obama Exec DACA amnesty but doesn't disavow previous support for Congress passing such an amnesty
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Graham: would change his Gang8 amnesty & 2X immi bill in light of security issues Says crazy after Paris not to have Syrian refugee timeout
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Huckabee resents ppl telling him how to be a Christian by insisting on risky refugee resettlement. #GOPDebate
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
CNN says Pataki says wouldn't take any Syrian refugees. Pataki says he agrees with Santorum's stmts to protect in home region #GOPDebate
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Santorum:Last thing to do is relocate moderate Muslims & Christian minorities out of area b/c they're needed to re-establish friendly state
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Santorum:Clerical leaders of religious minorities in Syria don't want their ppl relocated so they never return. Not going home if come to US
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Santorum: Shouldn't take people out of Syrian region & into U.S. Protect them at home. #GOPDebate
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Syrian refugees: Santorum says no proper way to vet from ISIS-controlled areas. How do a background check? Who to call? #GOPDebate
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Huckabee calls for a complete pause on bringing in #refugees to U.S.
#GOPdebate
— NumbersUSA (@NumbersUSA) December 16, 2015
Pataki: No Syrian refugees...Whether it is the 10,000 Obama wants or the 60,000 Hillary Clinton wants.
#GOPdebate
— NumbersUSA (@NumbersUSA) December 16, 2015
Santorum: How can you do a background check on someone from an ISIS controlled region? It's impossible...
#GOPdebate
— NumbersUSA (@NumbersUSA) December 16, 2015
Graham suggests rule that people who pledge allegiance to enemies of U.S. can't get a marriage immigrant green card. #GOPDebate
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Pataki: Would change Obama rule that kept immigration vetting from seeing the Pakistani murderer's social media desires to harm Ams.
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Pataki: Absurd Obama Admin so politically correct it has rule not to check soc. media of a potential immigrant for advocacy of harm to U.S
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Pataki says Obama admin has a rule against looking at social media postings of people applying to come to the US & rule must go.
#GOPDebate
— NumbersUSA (@NumbersUSA) December 16, 2015
Huck: How can Ams. trust gov't to properly vet more millions of refugees from a region of terrorists? #GOPDebate
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Huckabee: shining light on lack of screening of imms. San Bernardino killer had 3 background checks all missed her social media radicalism
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Kasich: "I must keep the people of my state safe, so we need a pause [to refugee resettlement]" #GOPDebate
— NumbersUSA (@NumbersUSA) December 16, 2015
Kasich says Obama placing border surgers in Ohio disrupted schools, "bad things happened" so the Admin's assurance on vetting not reassuring
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Kasich complains Admin placed Central Am. border crashers in Ohio without telling officials who later find out some were human traffickers.
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
FBI Dir. Comey one of most mentioned ppl in both debates His honesty about inability to guarantee vetting a big factor tonight.
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Christie doesn't flinch at simplistic biblical interpretation from the FB ? Ways to embrace needy beside work permits in other countries
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
CNN gave Jeb a chance to bash others on stage for being too tough on immigration & he declined. Good sign #GOPDebate
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Liked Jeb's response on imm. debate for Hispanics Instead of pandering, acknowledged that debate needed & backed border, enforcement ideas.
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Rand Paul plugs his refugee moratorium bill https://t.co/Yj9xId9RoC #GOPDebate
— NumbersUSA (@NumbersUSA) December 16, 2015
Huge kudos to Paul for emphasizing that LEGAL immigration is where most terrorism has come from in this country #GOPDebate
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Cruz deftly turns Trump Muslim controversy to his more targeted proposal: stop refugee resettlemnt from countries controlled by terrorists
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
Paul: To defend the country, you have to defend the border. #GOPDebate
— Roy Beck (@RoyBeck_NUSA) December 16, 2015
ROY BECK is President & Founder of NumbersUSA